How to choose affiliate software

Affiliate software tracks the clicks and sales your partners send, works out what you owe them and pays them. This guide lists what to compare, why each point matters and what to ask every vendor before you sign.

  • 9 criteria explained
  • 10 questions to ask
  • No product rankings

Vendor scorecard

Sample scorecard
Sample scorecard for two unnamed vendors
CriterionVendor AVendor B
Server-side trackingYesYes
Attribution rulesYesAsk
Billing connectionAskYes
Commission modelsYesNo
Holds and fraud checksNoYes

Fill one in for every vendor. “Ask” means the answer is not public.

Who needs affiliate software

You need it once partners send enough sales that a spreadsheet stops being reliable. These are the usual signs.

  • You pay partners from a spreadsheet

    Someone copies sales from your billing tool, works out each commission by hand and sends payments one by one. Mistakes and late payments follow.

  • Partners ask for numbers you cannot show

    Partners want to see their clicks, sales and balance at any time. Without a portal, every question becomes an email.

  • You sell subscriptions or use coupon codes

    Renewals, refunds and code-only sales are hard to credit by hand. Software links each one to the right partner.

  • You plan to add partner types

    Affiliates, creators, resellers and customers who refer friends each need their own terms. Software keeps those terms apart.

What to compare, and why

Each criterion and the reason it matters. None of it is specific to one vendor. What to check for each one is in the checklist.

1. Tracking that does not depend on the browser

Many affiliate tools start with a cookie in the visitor's browser. That works until the buyer switches device, clears cookies or uses a blocker. Server-to-server tracking stores the click on the vendor's servers and lets your backend report the sale, so the record does not depend on the browser.

2. Attribution rules you control

Ask how long a click stays valid, whether the first or the last partner gets credit and what happens when a buyer clicks one partner's link but uses another partner's coupon. These rules cause most partner disputes, so you want them written down and set in the software, not decided case by case.

3. A direct connection to your billing or store

Your billing platform or store already knows every sale, renewal and refund. If the affiliate software reads those events directly, commissions follow real money. If it does not, someone has to fix the gaps by hand each month.

4. Commission models that match your deals

Start with the deals you have today, then the ones you expect next year. Most programs need a fixed amount per sale or lead, a percentage of revenue or both. Growing programs add tiers, custom rates for top partners and commissions on every subscription renewal.

5. Holds, refunds and fraud checks

A refund after the payout means you paid for nothing, unless the software can reverse the commission. A hold period gives refunds time to show up. Fraud rules catch self-referrals and fake clicks before you approve anything.

6. Payouts in a few clicks

Count the steps between approved commissions and paid partners. Good software groups everything that is due into one batch, respects each partner's minimum and currency and lets partners choose how they get paid.

7. A partner portal under your brand

Partners need their links, creatives, stats and balance in one place. A portal on your domain, with your logo and your emails, makes the program feel like part of your company, not a third-party tool.

8. A price that does not take a cut

Affiliate software is usually priced as a flat subscription, a fee per transaction or a share of partner revenue. For each vendor, work out the cost at twice your current partner revenue. Ask what counts toward each limit and what happens when you go over.

9. Your data, and a way out

Check that you can export every click, conversion and payout, not only report totals. Ask whether the API covers the same data and how old links keep working if you ever leave. A vendor that makes leaving hard makes every price talk harder too.

Questions to ask every vendor

Send the same questions to each vendor, us included, and compare the written answers.

  1. Which tracking methods do you support: server-to-server, a browser script, coupon codes or all three?

  2. Where is the click stored, and for how long?

  3. Which partner gets credit when two partners sent the same buyer?

  4. Which billing and store platforms connect without custom code?

  5. How are refunds handled after a commission is paid?

  6. Which payout methods are built in, and who pays the payout fees?

  7. Can partners use a portal on our domain, with our brand?

  8. What is the price based on, and what happens when we pass a limit?

  9. Can we export every click, conversion and payout at any time?

  10. If we leave, how do our partners' links keep working?

The checklist

One row for each criterion. Copy it into your own sheet and add a column for each vendor.

Checklist for choosing affiliate software
CriterionWhy it mattersWhat to check
Tracking that does not depend on the browserAd blockers, private browsing and short cookie lifetimes lose sales that only a browser cookie recorded.
  • Server-to-server postbacks as well as a JavaScript tracker
  • A click ID that your billing or checkout can store
  • Coupon codes that credit a partner with no click at all
Attribution rules you controlThe rules decide which partner gets paid when two partners sent the same buyer.
  • A cookie length and attribution window you can change
  • First-click or last-click credit
  • A clear rule for click versus coupon
A direct connection to your billing or storeSales, renewals and refunds should reach the software without anyone copying them.
  • A ready integration for your billing or store platform
  • Renewals and refunds read from the same source
  • A postback or API option for anything custom
Commission models that match your dealsYour best partners will ask for terms that differ from your default rate.
  • Fixed, percentage and hybrid commissions per offer
  • Tiers and per-partner overrides
  • Recurring commissions for a set number of months or for life
Holds, refunds and fraud checksYou should not pay commission on a sale that is refunded or fake.
  • A hold period before commissions are approved
  • Automatic reversal on refunds and chargebacks
  • Fraud rules you can see and change
Payouts in a few clicksPaying partners late or by hand is a fast way to lose them.
  • Mass payouts in one batch
  • Payout thresholds and a schedule
  • The payout methods and currencies your partners need
A partner portal under your brandPartners judge your program by the portal they log in to every week.
  • Links, creatives, reports and payouts in the portal
  • Your logo, colors, domain and email templates
  • Control over which numbers partners see
A price that does not take a cutA fee on every sale grows with your success. A flat plan does not.
  • What the price is based on, and what makes it rise
  • Limits on partners, conversions, clicks or seats
  • What happens when you pass a limit
Your data, and a way outYou will need your data for disputes, finance and, one day, a move.
  • Full CSV export of raw clicks and conversions
  • An API with the same data
  • Old links kept working after a move

How trackspot.ai handles each criterion

These are our own answers, kept apart from the criteria. Check them in a trial, like any vendor's claims.

Questions about choosing affiliate software

What is the difference between affiliate software and network software?

Affiliate software runs your own program: you recruit partners, set the terms and pay them. Network software sits between many advertisers and many publishers and runs offers for all of them. If you run a network, read the network software guide.

Do I need affiliate software for a small program?

Not on day one. Once you pay more than a handful of partners each month, sell subscriptions or use coupon codes, manual tracking usually costs more time than software.

How long does setup take with trackspot.ai?

It depends on how you send conversions. The JavaScript tracker is one snippet on your site. A server-to-server postback needs one call from your server.

Can I test trackspot.ai against my current tool?

Yes. Start a 21-day trial with every live feature on, no card needed, and track the same traffic in parallel. Then compare the numbers.

Check trackspot.ai against this list

Start a 21-day trial with every live feature on and test each criterion with your own data. No card needed.